The short answer

For money you’ll need in six months to a year — a flat down payment, a wedding, school fees, a car — the goal is simple: keep it safe, keep it easy to get to, and earn a little more than a savings account. A liquid fund or a bank fixed deposit usually does this well. If you’re in a high tax bracket, an arbitrage fund can leave you with more after tax.

What doesn’t belong here is equity. Money you need within a year can’t afford a bad year in the markets.

Why a savings account isn’t enough

Savings accounts at large banks typically pay around 2.5% to 3% a year. Leaving ₹10 lakh there for a year while you wait for a flat to be ready gives up a noticeable amount compared with a liquid fund or FD. It’s not a fortune, but for money that’s just waiting, there’s no reason to earn less than you easily could.

Your options, side by side

Savings account Bank FD Liquid fund Arbitrage fund
Typical returnLowestFixed when you open itClose to short-term interest ratesSimilar to a liquid fund, varies more
Getting your moneyInstantPenalty if broken earlyNext working day; some allow up to ₹50,000 instantly2–3 working days; small exit charge if withdrawn within the first few weeks
How it’s taxedInterest at your slab rateInterest at your slab rate, every yearGains at your slab rate, only when you withdraw20% if held under a year; 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh after a year
Best forDay-to-day money and emergenciesWhen you know the exact date you’ll need itWhen the date might moveThe 30% tax bracket, and a year or more

How to choose

You know exactly when you’ll need the money. If the builder wants the payment on a fixed date nine months from now, an FD for that term is simple and certain. You know what you’ll get on the day.

You’re not sure of the date. Possession dates slip and plans change. A liquid fund lets you take out money any working day, with no penalty after the first week, and you can withdraw part of it without breaking the rest. That flexibility is often worth more than a small difference in return.

You’re in the 30% tax bracket. Interest from an FD and gains from a liquid fund are both taxed at your slab rate. Arbitrage funds are taxed like equity funds: 20% on gains if you sell within a year, and 12.5% on gains above ₹1.25 lakh after a year. For someone in the 30% bracket, that can mean noticeably more money in hand, especially if you can wait a little over a year. In a lower tax bracket, the advantage shrinks or disappears.

Despite the name, arbitrage funds are low-risk. They buy shares and sell them in the futures market at the same time, earning the small price difference between the two, so they don’t depend on the market going up.

A few things to avoid

  • Equity funds, even “safe-looking” large-cap funds. A 15% fall just before you need the money is a real possibility over any single year.
  • Funds that promise noticeably higher returns than other short-term funds. In debt funds, higher return usually means lower-quality borrowers. Stick to liquid, overnight, money market or arbitrage funds for this kind of money.
  • Very high FD rates from small or unfamiliar lenders. Bank deposits are insured only up to ₹5 lakh per person per bank. If a rate looks much better than the big banks’, ask why.

When it’s different

  • It’s your emergency fund. Keep a portion — say a month’s expenses — in your savings account for instant access, and the rest in a liquid fund.
  • It’s business money. Surplus cash between receivables and payments works the same way. Liquid funds are especially useful here, because you can withdraw exactly what you need, when you need it. We explain this more on our page for business owners.
  • The date is more than two or three years away. Then this isn’t really short-term money, and a more balanced mix may suit it better.

How we see it

This is one of the most common questions we get, and one of the least exciting to answer. That’s the point. Money you’ll need soon should be boring. If a suggestion for your down payment involves an equity fund or a new fund offer, it’s worth asking who that suggestion really suits.

For the record, liquid funds pay us almost nothing in commission. We recommend them anyway when they’re the right fit, and for this kind of money they usually are. Talk to us if you’d like help choosing.

CurateMyMoney is an AMFI-registered mutual fund distributor (ARN-184811). Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully. Tax rules mentioned are as applicable at the time of writing and may change; please check the current rules or consult a tax professional before acting.